Disputes Quick Read: A different approach to witness evidence

QUICK READ

The working group set up to consider improvements to the giving of factual evidence in the Business and Property Courts has recently published its report. It has recommended some changes to current practice – largely directed at ensuring compliance with existing rules – but no radical reforms. We think that an opportunity has been missed.

It seems to us that witness statements are too long and too expensive, while the system of cross-examination can mean that witnesses do not get a fair opportunity to tell their story at trial.

The working party has suggested some evidence in chief in appropriate cases using the court's existing powers (provided that the issues to be addressed are already covered in a witness statement or, at least, a witness summary), but we don't think that goes far enough.

We would welcome a system of (much shorter) witness summaries. These summaries would cover the headline factual points. A witness would then have the chance to give some evidence in chief, before cross-examination.

This might not be suitable for every case, but could be part of a menu of options. The majority of the respondents to the working party's survey were not keen on a menu approach. Perhaps it should be revisited.

Services et Groupes Résolution des litiges

Dans cette série

Résolution des litiges

The sting and the tale

Andrew Howell and Natalia Faekova unpack an extraordinary case. A Mexican billionaire's strong fraud claim. Former Israeli intelligence operatives hired to target the defendant's solicitor. Secret recordings over wine and dinner. A judge who called it 'anathema to civil litigation' but may have been 'too lenient'.

19 novembre 2025

Résolution des litiges

Opening the doors: how the January 2026 pilot will transform access to court documents

During an LSLA lecture on transparency and open justice, Mrs Justice Cockerill, recently appointed as Deputy Head of Civil Justice, outlined a pilot practice direction (PD) that will place select court documents squarely in the public domain via a new, public-facing side of the electronic court file (CE-File).

21 octobre 2025

Résolution des litiges

Disputes Quick Read: Not your prerogative – the Independent Review of Administrative Law reports its recommendations on judicial review

21 avril 2021

Résolution des litiges

Disputes Quick Read: Should you still choose the English courts to have jurisdiction in your international contracts after Brexit?

12 janvier 2021

Résolution des litiges

Disputes Quick Read: A different approach to witness evidence

Dans cette série

Related Insights

All change for the UK's product safety regime?

Who can do what in litigation? The Mazur decision explained

The UK's economic crime revolution: navigating the new era of corporate criminal liability